Can you reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity?
We can’t understand how quantum mechanics and the general theory of relativity could reconcile without first understanding how they — right now — do not. Because it turns out that neither one really works if the other is true. Einstein said that space-time is a smooth constant, and that only big things can warp it.
Why does quantum mechanics contradict general relativity?
Quantum mechanics is incompatible with general relativity because in quantum field theory, forces act locally through the exchange of well-defined quanta.
Why is quantum field theory incompatible with general relativity?
Quantum theory does not provide a natural time parameter and the quantum constraints of general relativity do not contain any time parameter. For this reason, standard quantum mechanics needs to be generalized to accommodate quantum spacetime, very probably without a Hilbert space.
Why did Albert Einstein not like quantum mechanics?
Einstein always believed that everything is certain, and we can calculate everything. That’s why he rejected quantum mechanics, due to its factor of uncertainty.
Who won the quantum debate between Einstein and Bohr?
Bohr
However, the EPR paper introduced topics that form the foundation for much of today’s physics research. Einstein and Niels Bohr began disputing Quantum Theory at the prestigious 1927 Solvay Conference, attended by top physicists of the day. By most accounts of this public debate, Bohr was the victor.
Who is Shiraz Minwalla?
Shiraz Naval Minwalla (born January 2, 1972) is an Indian theoretical physicist and string theorist. He is a faculty member in the Department of Theoretical Physics at Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai. Prior to his present position, Minwalla was a Harvard Junior Fellow and subsequently an assistant professor at Harvard University.
Can general relativity make peace with quantum physics?
Or put another way, general relativity would be forced to make peace with quantum physics, because the space in which physicists measure the effects of relativity would itself be divided into unbreakable quantum units. The theatre of reality in which gravity acts would take place on a quantum stage.
What is the clash between relativity and quantum mechanics?
The clash between relativity and quantum mechanics happens when you try to analyse what gravity is doing over extremely short distances, he notes, so he has decided to get a really good look at what is happening right there.
Is quantum mechanics more fundamental than general relativity?
“Most of us in this game believe that quantum mechanics is much more fundamental than general relativity is,” he says. That has been the prevailing view ever since the 1920s, when Einstein tried and repeatedly failed to find flaws in the counterintuitive predictions of quantum theory.